Skip to content
Case studies CrossVal

How CrossVal moved from a 0.2% reply rate to 6.1% in six weeks

CrossVal, a Dubai AI accounting company, had a 0.2% reply rate and no qualified pipeline. Cabot Insights rebuilt the ICP, cleaned the data, rewrote the offer and ran email and LinkedIn campaigns. In six weeks the reply rate reached 6.1%, qualification time fell from 3 hours to 30 minutes, and CrossVal added $220k of qualified pipeline.

Dubai, United Arab Emirates · AI-powered accounting and bookkeeping · Ajinkya Tanpure, Founder and CEO

6.1%Reply rate, from 0.2%
$220kQualified pipeline, from $0
30 minsAverage lead qualification time, from 3 hours
Challenge

A lot of outbound activity, and a 0.2% reply rate.

CrossVal had partnered with another Clay agency that promised rapid list-building, automations and done-for-you outbound. On paper the work looked strong, but the results were not.

Generic lists

Lists were too generic, with little segmentation. Messaging lacked value, and data quality issues meant the team was reaching the wrong people with the wrong offer.

No qualified pipeline

Hundreds of emails and LinkedIn messages were sent each week, yet meaningful replies were rare. Outbound had become an expensive activity rather than a growth engine. Reply rates sat at 0.2%, and there was no qualified pipeline.

Too little agility

CrossVal was limited in how many workflows and campaigns it could run with the other agency, and it needed faster communication and execution.

What we built

ICP, data, offer and a campaign system with no cap.

Cabot Insights introduced a structured GTM engineering approach that combined data enrichment, ICP scoring and message optimisation.

ICP rebuild

CrossVal's ideal customer profile was redefined using Clay-powered scoring logic across industry, tech stack and online signals.

Data cleansing

Contacts were verified, enriched and deduplicated, creating a single trusted source of truth.

Offer and messaging refresh

Outbound offers were rewritten to align with buyer intent and product use cases.

Campaign systemisation

Multi-channel automation (email and LinkedIn) was implemented, with personalised sequencing and continuous feedback loops. Cabot placed no limit on how many campaigns CrossVal could run, so the team could test, iterate and go again.

Results

The shift in six weeks.

MetricBefore CabotAfter Cabot
Reply rates0.2%6.1%
New pipeline generated$0$220k qualified pipeline
Average lead qualification time3 hours30 minutes

The reply rate moved from 0.2% to 6.1% in six weeks. In the same window, CrossVal added $220k of qualified pipeline, and average lead qualification time fell from 3 hours to 30 minutes.

Tools used

The stack behind the work.

ClayICP scoring and data enrichment workflows
LinkedInMulti-channel outreach and engagement
HubSpotCRM integration and pipeline management
LemlistEmail campaign delivery and tracking
n8nAutomation orchestration and system connections
What the client says

From the founder and CEO.

Cabot didn't just manage outreach: they rebuilt our system from the ground up, and someone as hands-on as Stephen might be the difference between activity and actual traction.

Ajinkya TanpureFounder and CEO, CrossVal
FAQ

A few direct answers.

How much did CrossVal's outbound reply rate improve with Cabot Insights?

The reply rate went from 0.2% to 6.1% in six weeks.

How much pipeline did the CrossVal work create?

The source records $0 qualified pipeline before Cabot Insights and $220k of qualified pipeline after, generated in six weeks.

What changed after CrossVal moved on from its previous Clay agency?

Cabot rebuilt the ICP and lists in Clay, cleaned and enriched the data, rewrote the offers, and ran email and LinkedIn outreach through Lemlist, LinkedIn, HubSpot and n8n, with no cap on the number of campaigns. Average lead qualification time fell from 3 hours to 30 minutes.

How to start

Book a call.

A short call to look at where the manual work is sitting, and what a scored, enriched, infrastructure-backed market would look like for your team.